Adjuvant radiotherapy added no survival benefit in modern melanoma treatment

Adjuvant radiotherapy did not improve recurrence-free or overall survival, but concurrent systemic therapy did not increase radiotherapy-related toxicity.

KEY POINTS

  • This multicentre retrospective study identified 58 melanoma patients receiving adjuvant nodal radiotherapy at five Austrian and Swiss centres between 2018 and 2021, with a median follow-up of 26 months.
  • Radiotherapy was used for high-risk nodal features including trans-capsular extension in 56.9%, at least three involved lymph nodes in 36.2%, and lymphogenic recurrence in 17.2%. Median total dose was 48 Gy, and 70.7% received hypofractionated treatment.
  • Most patients also received modern systemic treatment: nivolumab in 60.3%, pembrolizumab in 12.1%, and BRAF/MEK inhibition in 27.6%. Radiotherapy was delivered upfront in 53.5%, concurrently in 31%, and after systemic therapy in 15.5%.
  • Concurrent systemic therapy did not increase acute radiotherapy toxicity compared with upfront radiotherapy: 77.8% versus 74.2%, p = 0.456. Most events were grade 1-2 radiodermatitis.
  • Severe toxicity was uncommon: only two patients (3.5%) experienced grade 3-4 acute toxicity, and one patient developed persistent grade 3 lymphedema as a late event.
  • Among upfront and concurrent radiotherapy patients, one- and two-year recurrence-free survival was 58.4% and 32.3% with upfront treatment versus 66.7% and 38.9% with concurrent treatment, with no significant difference (p = 0.536).
  • Compared with 88 stage-matched non-irradiated patients who also met formal radiotherapy criteria, adjuvant radiotherapy produced no significant improvement in recurrence-free survival (p = 0.725) or overall survival (p = 0.986). The comparison was exploratory and unadjusted.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

Routine adjuvant nodal radiotherapy appears difficult to justify in melanoma when effective systemic therapy is available, because no recurrence-free or overall survival advantage emerged. Its remaining role is likely selective, where locoregional control is particularly important or systemic options have failed, and concurrent delivery appears feasible.

SOURCE

Cancers

Browse more research Suggest a correction