Compact PBS maintains high throughput despite smaller fields and frequent couch flips

Across more than 215,000 delivered beams, a compact proton system maintained high throughput despite smaller fields and frequent couch flips.

KEY POINTS

  • This single-center analysis combined more than five years of beam log files with clinical data from three pencil-beam scanning rooms: two ProteusPLUS gantries and one compact ProteusONE. The dataset contained 120,367 delivered PBS beams on ProteusPLUS and 95,587 on ProteusONE.
  • During the final 18 months when all three rooms delivered PBS, mean daily throughput was 27.4 patients for GTR2, 22.9 for GTR1, and 27.0 for the compact ProteusONE room. Mean session times were 28.2, 25.6, and 26.9 minutes, respectively; only GTR2 versus GTR1 differed significantly.
  • Hardware differences strongly shaped case allocation. The large-field, larger-spot GTR2 predominantly treated prostate, breast, and thoracic targets, whereas the smaller-spot GTR1 and ProteusONE rooms concentrated more on prostate, head and neck, brain, and CNS cases.
  • The compact room carried a substantially more pediatric case mix: 25.2% of treatments involved pediatric patients, versus 7.1% in GTR2 and 5.8% in GTR1. Pediatric patients requiring anesthesia were preferentially grouped there for workflow efficiency.
  • 77% of ProteusONE treatments required a 180° couch flip, yet the room still delivered approximately 27 sessions per day, essentially matching the busiest ProteusPLUS room. This suggests that the partial gantry geometry did not materially limit routine clinical throughput.
  • Lower minimum beam energy had important practical consequences. Maximum cyclotron energy was used in 7.5% of GTR2 beams versus only 0.4% with ProteusONE, while overall range-shifter use remained similar at 71.1% and 67.0%. The lower 70-MeV minimum energy reduced the need for range shifting in shallow components of complex fields.
  • Based on all beams actually delivered, the authors estimate that a maximum proton energy of 220 MeV could cover approximately 98–99% of cases. This is an observational single-center estimate, however, and room assignment reflected both technical requirements and institutional practice patterns.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

Real-world proton-room efficiency depends on more than gantry size or field size alone: minimum energy, spot characteristics, imaging, layer switching, and workflow design can materially influence clinical capacity. These data are particularly useful for centers planning new proton infrastructure, but the conclusions remain platform- and institution-specific.

SOURCE

International Journal of Particle Therapy

Browse more research Suggest a correction