KEY POINTS
- This retrospective single-center study from University of Wisconsin–Madison evaluated 18 patients undergoing salvage microsurgery for progressive vestibular schwannoma after stereotactic irradiation between 2010 and 2024. Twelve patients had previously received irradiation without microsurgery, while six had undergone initial microsurgery followed by irradiation before repeat surgery. Among the irradiation-only patients, seven received fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) and five Gamma Knife radiosurgery.
- Previous radiation schedules included 12.5 Gy in one fraction with Gamma Knife or 20 Gy in five fractions with FSRT. Salvage surgery was considered after persistent radiological enlargement together with clinical deterioration, rather than after a single enlarging surveillance scan. Intraoperative facial nerve monitoring was used, and resection was intentionally limited when dissection risk threatened functional preservation. Gross total resection was achieved in 9/12 patients (75%) without prior surgery versus 3/6 (50%) with prior surgery.
- Favorable House–Brackmann (HB) grade I–II facial nerve function was present at final follow-up in all 12 irradiation-only patients. However, three patients (25%) experienced deterioration relative to their pre-salvage grade, demonstrating that preservation of HB I–II status does not necessarily mean preservation of baseline function. In the prior-surgery group, favorable HB I–II function was present in 2/6 patients both before salvage and at final follow-up, with two patients (33.3%) experiencing deterioration.
- Intraoperative dissection conditions differed between treatment-history groups. Using a study-specific, nonvalidated scoring system, dissection was classified as favorable in 10/12 irradiation-only patients but in none of the six previously operated patients. Mean operative duration was approximately 6.3 versus 7.1 hours, respectively. Dense tumor adherence, impaired arachnoid planes, and the need for sharp dissection were documented in selected cases, but these observations do not establish whether prior surgery, radiation, tumor size, or other factors independently determined technical difficulty.
- The two groups had markedly different baseline characteristics. Median pre-salvage tumor volume estimates were approximately 2.66 cm³ in irradiation-only patients versus 5.27 cm³ after previous microsurgery and irradiation. All irradiation-only patients had favorable baseline facial function, compared with only one-third of previously operated patients. Median postoperative follow-up was 51.5 versus 67.0 months, respectively. These differences prevent valid direct conclusions about the relative safety of treatment sequences.
- Radiation modality comparisons were exploratory and inconclusive. Gamma Knife and FSRT recipients within the irradiation-only group represented very small subgroups, and no reliable independent association with final facial nerve outcomes was established. Tumor volume estimates were based on an ellipsoid approximation rather than volumetric segmentation, while hearing, tinnitus, and vertigo outcomes came from nonstandardized retrospective clinical documentation.
- The study does not quantify the overall risk of requiring salvage surgery after stereotactic irradiation. The 18 patients were selected from individuals who had already experienced progression and undergone surgery, without a denominator representing all irradiated vestibular schwannoma patients. No matched cohort of primary microsurgery patients was included. Consequently, the findings cannot establish the probability of irradiation failure, superiority of FSRT versus Gamma Knife, or a causal effect of irradiation on operative difficulty.
CLINICAL TAKEAWAY
Salvage microsurgery after failed stereotactic irradiation for vestibular schwannoma can preserve favorable facial nerve function in selected patients, but deterioration relative to baseline remains possible. Previous surgery, tumor characteristics, and difficult dissection conditions complicate treatment decisions, particularly when complete removal threatens the facial nerve. These observations support individualized multidisciplinary salvage planning but do not establish the superiority of a particular radiation or surgical strategy.