Physicist consultation improves treatment reproducibility in breast radiotherapy

Pre-treatment physicist consultation was associated with higher EPID gamma passing rates and smaller setup shifts during breast radiotherapy.

KEY POINTS

  • This prospective observational comparison included 40 women with breast cancer, with 20 receiving standard care and 20 undergoing an additional structured consultation with a medical physicist before CT simulation. All patients received 40.05 Gy in 15 fractions, delivered with IMRT or VMAT using daily SGRT and CBCT-based IGRT.
  • The physicist consultation lasted approximately 20 minutes and focused on treatment planning, positioning, immobilization, image guidance, surface guidance, and the importance of reproducing the simulation position. Patients were also shown the CT simulation and treatment rooms before starting therapy.
  • Interfraction treatment reproducibility was assessed with EPID-based in-vivo transit dosimetry, using each patient's first fraction as their own reference and a 3%/4 mm gamma criterion. Mean gamma passing rate was 99.25% in the consultation group versus 96.97% with standard care (p=3.1×10⁻⁶).
  • The same direction of effect was seen in exploratory technique-specific analyses. Mean gamma passing rate was 98.85% vs 97.11% for IMRT (p=0.0017) and 99.80% vs 96.90% for VMAT (p=0.0020) in consultation versus control patients, respectively.
  • Daily IGRT corrections also suggested better positional reproducibility. Mean vertical shifts decreased from 0.31 to 0.24 cm (p=0.030), and longitudinal shifts from 0.22 to 0.17 cm (p=0.048); the lateral reduction from 0.19 to 0.16 cm was not statistically significant.
  • Rotational differences were small and not statistically significant: pitch was 0.69° versus 0.63°, roll 0.50° versus 0.45°, and yaw 0.82° versus 0.78° for control and consultation patients, respectively.
  • The cohorts differed substantially in laterality, nodal irradiation, and treatment technique: 50% of consultation patients received VMAT versus 20% of controls, and nodal irradiation was used in 40% versus 15%. Moreover, the EPID analysis measured consistency against the first delivered fraction rather than agreement with planned patient dose, so the findings demonstrate reproducibility rather than absolute dosimetric accuracy.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

A short technical consultation before simulation may help patients reproduce their treatment position more consistently, suggesting a potentially useful patient-facing role for medical physicists beyond education and reassurance. The signal is objective but preliminary: the study included only 40 patients, was nonrandomized, and important treatment characteristics differed between groups.

SOURCE

Practical Radiation Oncology

Browse more research Suggest a correction