Time-driven proton PBS achieves FLASH dose rates on a clinical cyclotron without hardware changes

A nonclinical time-driven PBS configuration delivered 25 Gy in approximately 0.6 seconds at 42 Gy/s while preserving proton range and scanning accuracy.

KEY POINTS

  • This experimental study at the Cyclotron Centre Bronowice, Poland, evaluated a time-driven FLASH delivery method on a clinical IBA Proteus C235 pencil beam scanning system. The investigators used a 228.4 MeV proton beam and tested dose rate, beam transmission, proton range, spot geometry, and scanning accuracy at gantry angles of 0°, 180°, and 270°.
  • FLASH delivery was achieved without physical hardware modification by opening the energy-selection-system divergence-limiting slits from 9.1 × 4.2 mm² to 40 × 40 mm² and replacing charge-controlled spot termination with predefined irradiation times. Delivery was performed in Scanning Controller Diagnostic mode, with independently recorded charge measurements used for retrospective dosimetric verification rather than real-time charge-based spot termination.
  • At 228.4 MeV, beamline transmission increased from 8.3 ± 0.2% to 57.0 ± 0.3%, representing an approximately sevenfold gain. Beam current at the isocenter reached 273 nA, corresponding to approximately 1.7 × 10¹² protons per second and an estimated peak on-axis average dose rate of 2.0 × 10³ Gy/s for an individual pencil beam at the phantom entrance.
  • In a representative 11 × 11 spot field with 4-mm spacing, the system delivered 25 Gy in approximately 0.6 seconds, producing a measured average field dose rate of 42 Gy/s at 2 cm depth. Average field dose rates reached 90 Gy/s at higher delivered doses, although field-average values and peak dose rates within individual pencil beams describe different aspects of temporal irradiation.
  • Increasing transmission did not materially affect proton energy characteristics. Distal R80 agreed within 0.5 mm between conventional and FLASH configurations, while differences in Bragg peak width were below 0.2 mm. Measured FLASH spot size was approximately 3.0 mm, modestly larger than the approximately 2.5-mm reference clinical beam model.
  • Scanning accuracy remained stable across all three tested gantry angles, with spot-position deviations below 0.5 mm and median deviations of approximately 0.2–0.3 mm. Uniform 4 × 4 cm² fields were generated successfully, with flatness below 3% at 3-mm spot spacing and a minimum of approximately 1.8% at 270°, whereas wider spot spacing produced less homogeneous fields.
  • The proposed diagnostic delivery mode has important limitations, including an approximately 60-second sequence limit, a minimum 2-ms interspot interval, and the absence of real-time charge-based spot monitoring. The investigation was restricted to experimental dosimetry at one beam energy and did not evaluate radiobiological FLASH sparing, clinical treatment planning, or patient safety.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

Time-driven proton PBS delivery can achieve ultra-high dose rates on an existing clinical cyclotron while maintaining acceptable experimental range and scanning performance, offering a practical platform for FLASH radiobiology research. However, the technique remains nonclinical, requires independent quantitative dosimetry, and does not establish the biological FLASH effect or readiness for patient treatment.

SOURCE

Physics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology

Browse more research Suggest a correction