User-derived electrometer calibration factors remain stable over 28 months with minimal uncertainty impact

Across three electrometers, user-derived calibration factors remained stable over 28 months, with negligible drift-related uncertainty and consistent results across input methods.

KEY POINTS

  • This technical study evaluated long-term stability of user-derived electrometer calibration factors (kₑₗₑc,user) over 28 months. A traceably calibrated RAMTEC Solo served as the reference electrometer, while UNIDOSwebline, RAMTEC Duo, and Super MAX were evaluated through repeated sensitivity-ratio measurements.
  • Electrometer responses were compared using three independent signal-input approaches: a 10-MV TrueBeam LINAC, the battery-powered SCG002 current source, and the servo-controlled EMF521R current source. Measurements were performed at 1, 100, and 200 nC to assess sensitivity ratios across a clinically relevant charge range.
  • Measurement reproducibility was high for all three input methods. The maximum observed coefficient of variation was 0.071% with the LINAC method, compared with 0.0038% for EMF521R and 0.00089% for SCG002, supporting the precision of current-source-based measurements.
  • User-derived calibration coefficients obtained using the different input methods agreed within 0.1%, with a maximum relative difference of 0.06%. Their agreement with externally calibrated electrometer coefficients was also within approximately 0.06% across the evaluated instruments.
  • Over 28 months, linear regression showed very small changes in calibration-factor estimates. The largest slope occurred for RAMTEC Duo at 6.566 × 10⁻⁶ per month, corresponding to an estimated total drift of approximately 1.84 × 10⁻⁴, or 0.0184% of a near-unity calibration factor.
  • The largest estimated Type B standard uncertainty associated with long-term stability was approximately 0.0106%. Including this component did not materially change the overall uncertainty budget: combined standard uncertainty remained 0.20%, corresponding to 0.40% expanded uncertainty (k=2).
  • The results support periodic in-house sensitivity intercomparison as a complementary QA method, potentially using current sources without dedicated accelerator time. However, the analysis measured relative stability against a reference electrometer, not independently verified absolute accuracy, and cannot justify discontinuation of traceable external calibration.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

Periodic sensitivity comparisons using calibrated reference electrometers and reproducible current sources appear suitable for monitoring electrometer stability between external calibrations, with minimal additional uncertainty over more than two years. These findings can support practical departmental dosimetry QA workflows, but the method remains complementary to, rather than a replacement for, calibration traceability to recognized standards.

SOURCE

Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics

Browse more research Suggest a correction