Dose-averaged dose rate better predicts ion-chamber recombination in UHDR particle beams

In synchrotron UHDR proton and carbon-ion beams, dose-averaged dose rate better described chamber recombination than conventional field-averaged metrics.

KEY POINTS

  • This experimental dosimetry study investigated ionization-chamber recombination in synchrotron-based ultra-high-dose-rate (UHDR) proton and carbon-ion beams at the Heidelberg Ion-Beam Therapy Center, Germany. Measurements used 146.56-MeV protons and 274.98-MeV/u carbon ions, with scanned and scattered delivery configurations. Three commercial detectors were evaluated: PTW 34045 Advanced Markus, PTW 31023 PinPoint, and PTW 31009 PinPoint, with charge-collection efficiency and saturation correction factors assessed across multiple applied voltages.
  • Three different dose-rate descriptors were compared: field-averaged dose rate (DRField), local pencil-beam-scanning dose rate (DRPBS), and dose-averaged dose rate (DADR). DRField represents dose divided by complete field-delivery time, DRPBS accounts for the local effective irradiation window, and DADR preferentially weights high-intensity portions of the instantaneous dose-rate waveform. Their suitability for predicting recombination was assessed using analytical Boag calculations and a numerical FLASH Ionization Chamber Model (FICM).
  • The choice of dose-rate definition produced large numerical differences for the same irradiation. In scanned proton beams, measured DRField, DRPBS, and DADR were 173.7, 227.1, and 538.5 Gy/s, respectively. Corresponding values for scanned carbon ions were 103.0, 245.3, and 401.3 Gy/s. For scattered carbon ions, DRField and DRPBS were relatively similar (75.7 and 79.1 Gy/s), whereas DADR reached 157.7 Gy/s. These differences demonstrate why nominal field dose rate may poorly represent the instantaneous ionization conditions experienced by a detector.
  • DADR provided the closest overall agreement between analytical recombination predictions and measurements, particularly in scanned beams. Within Boag's model, DRField generally underestimated recombination, whereas DADR produced larger correction factors and better reproduced the observed decline in charge-collection efficiency. However, DADR alone did not eliminate disagreement, especially for cylindrical chambers at lower voltages, indicating that the chamber response model remains important.
  • The numerical FICM improved predictions for cylindrical ionization chambers. Unlike the simplified effective-gap representation in Boag's analytical approach, FICM modeled geometry-dependent charge transport, electron attachment, ion recombination, and space-charge effects. The improvement was particularly relevant for the larger PTW 31009, which exhibited greater recombination and larger discrepancies between measured and analytical correction factors. The Advanced Markus and PTW 31023 demonstrated the most robust behavior under the investigated irradiation conditions.
  • A numerical validity analysis identified conditions under which DADR-based quasi-static calculations remain reliable. For simulated Gaussian pulses, agreement between the transient response and a continuous-beam approximation remained within 1% when pulse duration was at least approximately three times the chamber ion-collection time and charge-collection efficiency was ≥83%. This condition held for investigated peak dose rates up to 30,000 Gy/s. These thresholds are conservative applicability criteria derived from the tested model configurations, not universal chamber specifications.
  • The proposed framework does not replace detector-specific commissioning or time-resolved measurements. Scanned and scattered experiments were performed in separate campaigns, and saturation-charge estimates relied on voltage-series extrapolation rather than simultaneous independent beam-monitor normalization. In addition, full-spill responses were approximated using effective dose-rate inputs rather than complete chronological transport simulation. The results therefore support a more appropriate framework for evaluating chamber recombination, but not a universal correction factor or a definitive definition of biologically relevant FLASH dose rate.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

For synchrotron-based UHDR proton and carbon-ion dosimetry, dose-averaged dose rate describes the ionization conditions relevant to chamber recombination more consistently than conventional field-averaged metrics. However, accurate correction also requires a chamber-specific response model and consideration of charge-collection times, temporal beam structure, and operating voltage. These findings are relevant to detector commissioning and experimental UHDR dosimetry but do not establish a universal recombination correction or validate clinical FLASH dose delivery.

SOURCE

Zeitschrift für Medizinische Physik

Browse more research Suggest a correction