Twenty-fraction head and neck radiotherapy was feasible in older and comorbid patients

Ninety-five percent completed 55 Gy in 20 fractions, with encouraging outcomes in early p16-positive oropharyngeal cancer despite substantial acute toxicity.

KEY POINTS

  • This two-center UK retrospective cohort included 119 patients receiving definitive 55 Gy in 20 fractions between 2018 and 2025, excluding early glottic cancer. Mean age was 72 years, 57% had an Adult Comorbidity Evaluation score ≥2 and 37% had performance status ≥2.
  • Treatment used VMAT, with elective nodal regions receiving 44 Gy in 20 fractions when indicated. Most patients (76%) received treatment to the primary tumor and bilateral neck; concurrent chemotherapy was not routinely used and only one historical patient received platinum.
  • Treatment completion was high despite the frail population: 113/119 patients (95%) completed all planned fractions. Four of the six discontinuations were caused by toxicity, one by rapid cancer progression and one by non-compliance.
  • Acute toxicity remained substantial. At treatment completion, 64% had grade 3 mucositis, 39% grade 3 dysphagia, 38% grade 2 skin toxicity and 62% grade 2 salivary toxicity; four weeks later, grade 3 mucositis had fallen to 26% and grade 3 dysphagia to 21%.
  • Gastrostomy tubes were used in 54 patients (45%), most prophylactically. Nineteen tubes (35%) were removed within three months, whereas 8/54 patients (15%) remained tube-dependent for at least 12 months and another 15 died within 12 months with the tube still in place.
  • Overall complete response among treatment completers was 67%. In evaluable p16-positive oropharyngeal disease, complete response was 86%; among early-stage p16-positive tumors it reached 90%, with three-year overall survival 85% and recurrence-free survival 78%.
  • Across the whole heterogeneous cohort, one-, two- and three-year overall survival was 76%, 60% and 44%. Stage and comorbidity independently predicted survival, while interpretation by tumor subsite is limited by small numbers, retrospective toxicity scoring and sparse late-toxicity assessment beyond gastrostomy dependence.

CLINICAL TAKEAWAY

A four-week 55-Gy/20-fraction course can deliver radical treatment to selected older or comorbid head and neck patients who may struggle with conventional six- to seven-week schedules. Acute mucosal toxicity remains considerable, and because this cohort has no contemporary control group, the study supports feasibility and selection rather than proving equivalence on its own.

SOURCE

Clinical Oncology